Last checked
Reviewed by Josh
Key points
The short answer
If you own a short let, you rarely have to choose between Airbnb and direct bookings. The large booking sites bring a steady stream of guests who already trust the brand. Direct bookings give you more control over the guest relationship and avoid a platform's service fee. Many well-run homes use both, with one calendar and one pricing plan behind them.
So the useful question is not which channel wins. It is how much of your income depends on any single source, and what each booking really costs you once every fee and every job is counted.
How an Airbnb booking works for you
When a guest books through Airbnb, the company handles search, payment and messaging, and its host protection terms sit in the background. In return it charges a service fee. Depending on the fee model your account uses, that fee may be shared between you and the guest or charged mainly to you as the host.
We do not quote Airbnb's fee rates in this guide, because they change and can vary by account. Check Airbnb's current host help pages before you run any comparison, and look at what actually reached your bank on recent payouts rather than the headline nightly price.
What the fee buys is reach and convenience. What you give up is some control. The site sets the rules on cancellations, reviews, how you can contact guests and, to a large degree, where your home appears in search results.
What a direct booking really costs
A direct booking is one a guest makes with you, or with your manager, rather than through a third-party site. It avoids the platform's service fee, but it is not free. Someone has to pay for, and run:
a booking website that is secure, quick and easy to use on a phone
online payments, including card processing charges and refunds
your own terms, cancellation policy and house rules
guest checks and security deposits, because no booking site is screening anyone for you
insurance that covers paying guests, since there is no platform protection scheme to fall back on
marketing, so that guests can find the website in the first place
answering enquiries, often from people who never go on to book
For a single owner with one property, those costs and jobs can easily outweigh the fee you save. For a manager running many homes through one booking site, they are shared across a whole portfolio. That is why direct booking tends to make more sense at scale.
Side by side
| Through a large booking site | Booked direct | |
|---|---|---|
| Who finds the guest | The site's search and brand | Your website, returning guests and word of mouth |
| Who takes payment | The site | You or your manager |
| Main costs | The site's service fee | Card charges, website upkeep and marketing |
| Guest checks | Partly done by the site, plus your own | Entirely your responsibility |
| If there is damage | The site's host protection terms, plus any deposit | Your deposit and your insurance |
| Guest relationship | Run through the site's messaging and rules | Yours, within data protection rules |
| Effort for a solo owner | Lower | Higher |
How much of your mix can come direct?
There is no correct percentage, and you should be wary of anyone who promises one. The share of direct bookings a home can win depends on things like:
how many guests return, which tends to be higher with contractors, visiting families and people coming for regular events
whether there is a recognisable brand and a proper website behind the property
how easily that website is found in search
whether past guests are invited back, with their consent
For most owners, direct bookings build slowly. Treat them as a valuable extra route that reduces your reliance on any one site, rather than as a replacement for the large booking sites.
Guest checks, deposits and protection on direct stays
This is where direct bookings need the most care. With nobody in the middle, nobody else has looked at the guest, and there is no platform scheme to claim against if something goes wrong.
Before you take direct bookings, make sure you have:
a clear way to check who is booking, including identity checks where appropriate
a security deposit, taken and released on terms the guest has agreed
insurance that explicitly covers short-term paying guests
written house rules that the guest accepts before arrival
If a manager runs your direct bookings, ask exactly how guests are vetted and who holds the deposit.
Why many owners use both
Running both routes spreads the risk. If one site changes its search ranking, its fees or its rules, your calendar does not empty overnight. Meanwhile, the large sites keep filling the dates that direct guests leave open.
The catch is coordination. Every channel has to show the same availability, or you risk selling the same night twice. Prices need managing across all of them as well. That is usually handled with a channel manager that keeps calendars in step, together with pricing that is reviewed often, ideally every day.
Does the booking route change your legal duties?
No. The rules that apply to your property apply however the guest booked. In Wales, anyone responsible for visitor accommodation who takes bookings of 31 nights or less must register with the Welsh Revenue Authority. In Cardiff, the visitor levy applies to stays from 1 April 2027, at £1.30 per person per night for self-catering homes, whether the guest came through a large site or your own website. Our Cardiff visitor levy guide explains how it works.
Fire safety and gas safety duties are the same for every booking too.
How StayRight handles direct bookings
StayRight runs its own booking site, and the homes we manage are added to it as part of full management. Alongside that, your home is listed on 20+ platforms. You get a direct route for guests without building or marketing a website yourself.
Direct and platform bookings are treated alike. Pricing is tuned daily across every channel, guests are vetted and security deposits taken, and our in-house team supports guests 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. Housekeeping comes with hotel-quality linen, and every stay shows up on your owner dashboard.
See how it works on our direct bookings page, read about pricing and revenue, or talk to the team about your property.
Direct bookings are part of how we manage homes in Cardiff, Swansea and across our other areas.
Sources
This guide is general information, not legal or tax advice. Check the sources above or speak to an adviser for your situation.
Questions
Is it cheaper for guests to book direct?
It can be. A direct booking avoids any guest service fee a booking site would add, so the same nightly rate can cost the guest less. Some owners pass part of that saving on to reward direct guests, while others keep prices the same everywhere. Either approach can work, as long as the price still covers your costs.
Can I take direct bookings while my home is on Airbnb?
In general, yes, as long as every channel shares one calendar so a night is never sold twice. Airbnb sets its own rules on how hosts deal with guests who found them there, so read its current terms before contacting those guests outside it.
What is a good direct booking percentage?
There is no standard figure that applies to every home. A city flat that suits returning contractors may win more direct stays than a seaside cottage that mostly gets first-time visitors. The better aim is steady growth in returning guests, without letting your other channels slip.
Do direct guests pay the Cardiff visitor levy?
The levy is charged on the stay, not on the booking route. The accommodation provider is liable for it and pays it to the Welsh Revenue Authority, and can choose either to pass it on to guests or absorb it. Stays in Cardiff from 1 April 2027 are covered, however they were booked.