Last checked
Reviewed by Josh
Key points
The short answer
Most companies that manage short lets charge a share of what your property earns, but that headline percentage tells you surprisingly little on its own. Two quotes with the same figure can leave you with quite different amounts, depending on what the percentage is charged on, whether VAT is added, and which jobs are billed separately.
We have deliberately not printed a market range here. Managers word their fees in different ways and change them often, so a single range would mislead more than it would help. Instead, this guide shows you how to compare any quote properly. If you want StayRight's own fee, it is on our pricing page.
The main ways managers charge
A share of booking income
The manager takes an agreed percentage of the income from each stay. Because their pay rises and falls with yours, they have a reason to keep the calendar full at sensible rates. This is a familiar model for full management, where one company runs pricing, guests, cleaning and maintenance.
A fixed monthly fee
Some managers charge a flat amount each month. It is predictable, but the manager earns the same whether your home is busy or quiet. If you are offered this, ask how they will keep pricing and occupancy up when their income does not depend on it.
Co-host or part-service fees
A co-host typically takes on some jobs, such as guest messages and arranging cleans, while you keep the rest. The fee reflects a narrower service, so compare it against the work you would still be doing yourself, including evenings and weekends.
Rent-style arrangements
Some companies offer to rent your property and run it themselves, paying you a set rent while keeping any profit above it. You gain predictability and give up the upside. Read these agreements with care: check how they sit with your mortgage, lease and insurance, who carries the compliance duties, and what happens if the rent stops arriving.
What is the percentage charged on?
This is the most important question, and the one owners most often miss. A percentage fee might be worked out on:
the full amount the guest pays, including any cleaning fee
the booking value after the booking site has taken its service fee
the booking value after cleaning and other costs have been deducted
the nightly rate alone
Each of these produces a different payout from the same stay. Ask every manager to take one example booking for your home and show you, line by line, what would land in your account. If the answer is vague, ask for it in writing.
Is VAT included?
Management fees charged by a VAT-registered business are normally subject to VAT. Some managers quote with VAT included and others quote before VAT, which can make one offer look cheaper than it is. Ask each manager directly, and put every quote on the same footing before you compare.
What the fee covers, and what may cost extra
Packages vary a great deal, so list what each one includes before you compare prices. Items that some managers charge for separately include:
cleaning and laundry between stays
linen and towels, whether rented, bought or replaced
guest supplies such as toiletries, tea and coffee
setting the property up: furnishing, photography, writing the listing and arranging safety checks
maintenance call-outs, parts and contractor time
booking site service fees and card processing charges
A higher fee that includes cleaning, linen and maintenance can cost you less overall than a lower fee with everything added on top. The only way to know is to cost both on the same example.
Contract terms that change the real cost
The fee is only one part of the deal. Read the agreement for:
the length of any minimum term and the notice period
exit fees or charges for leaving early
who keeps the listing, photos and reviews if you leave
who holds guest deposits and how damage claims are handled
how and when you are paid, and how you can see every booking and deduction
the repair spending a manager can approve without asking you first
who is responsible for compliance, such as registration in Wales, gas safety checks and the fire risk assessment
Long lock-ins and heavy exit fees are worth questioning, even where the headline percentage looks attractive.
A simple way to compare quotes
Choose one realistic example booking for your property, in a typical month.
Ask each manager to show what you would receive from it after their fee, VAT and every other charge.
Ask what would happen in a quiet month, after a damaged sofa, and when a guest is locked out late at night.
Compare the jobs left with you, not just the money.
Check reviews from owners as well as guests, and ask to speak to a current client.
Our guide to choosing an Airbnb management company goes further into the questions to ask and the warning signs to watch for.
What StayRight charges
StayRight's fee for full management is 12.5% + VAT.
The pricing page sets out what that covers: pricing tuned daily, guest vetting and security deposits, in-house guest support, housekeeping with hotel-quality linen, maintenance, full property set-up, an owner dashboard and automatic payouts. You can read how cleaning and maintenance work in practice. If you want to see what your home might earn before you compare managers, ask for an income estimate.
You can see the homes we look after in each area on our pages for Cardiff, Swansea, Birmingham, Nottingham and Bristol.
Sources
This guide is general information, not legal or tax advice. Check the sources above or speak to an adviser for your situation.
Questions
Is a percentage fee better than a fixed fee?
Neither is right for everyone. A percentage links the manager's pay to your results, which many owners like. A fixed fee is easier to budget for but gives the manager less reason to push your income up. Whichever you choose, compare the money you would actually receive.
Does a management fee include cleaning?
Sometimes. Some managers include housekeeping and linen in their fee, while others charge them separately or pass them to the guest as a cleaning fee. Ask for a written list of what is in and what is out.
Can I leave a management contract early?
That depends entirely on your agreement. Look for the notice period, any minimum term and any exit fees before you sign, and ask what happens to your listing, reviews and future bookings when you leave.
Why can two quotes with the same percentage pay out differently?
Because the percentage may be applied to different amounts. One manager might charge it on the full price the guest pays, another on the amount left after booking site fees and cleaning. VAT and extra charges then widen the gap.