Last checked
Reviewed by Josh
Key points
The short answer
There is no universal winner. A long-term let usually gives you steadier income with less day-to-day involvement. A well-run short let can earn more in the right place, but its income moves with the seasons, it costs more to run, and it carries more rules. The right answer depends on your property, its location, your finances and how much involvement you want.
This guide sets out the trade-offs honestly. It does not include income or yield figures, because any average would say little about your particular home. For a figure based on your property, ask us for an income estimate.
How the money works
Long-term let
You receive a fixed monthly rent from a tenant, usually unfurnished or part-furnished. The tenant normally pays the utilities and council tax. Your main risks are gaps between tenants, arrears, and wear and tear over the length of the tenancy.
Short let
You receive income night by night. Rates can rise for busy weekends, events and holidays, and fall in quiet weeks. In return, you take on costs a landlord usually avoids:
furnishing and equipping the home to a standard guests expect
cleaning, laundry and linen between every stay
utilities, broadband and streaming services
council tax, or business rates if the property qualifies
booking site service fees and card charges
the visitor levy, where a council charges one
a management fee, if you do not run it yourself
Our guide to how much your property could earn explains what drives short-let income up and down.
Tax since the holiday let regime ended
Until recently, holiday lets that met certain tests had their own tax treatment, known as the Furnished Holiday Lettings regime. It was abolished from April 2025. Former holiday lets are now taxed as part of the owner's ordinary property business, in much the same way as other residential lets. For owners this meant:
Mortgage interest: no longer fully deductible. Relief is restricted to a basic rate tax credit, as it is for other residential lets.
Capital allowances: no new claims for furniture and equipment under the old rules, although existing pools can continue to be written down. Replacement of domestic items relief applies instead.
Selling up: the business reliefs on capital gains that used to apply to holiday lets are no longer available, apart from limited transitional rules.
Pensions: profits no longer count as relevant earnings for pension contributions.
The tax gap between short and long lets is therefore narrower than it was. The property allowance, which lets individuals receive up to £1,000 of property income a year tax-free, applies to both.
Another change is on the way. As of 21 October 2026, the law sets separate tax rates on property income of 22%, 42% and 47% from 6 April 2027, for England, Wales and Northern Ireland. The UK Government has said it will work with the Welsh Government to let Wales set its own property income rates, so the rates for Welsh taxpayers may change. Speak to an accountant before deciding, because your own position may look quite different from the general picture.
Regulation and paperwork
Both routes carry rules, but they are different rules.
A long-term let in Wales is usually an occupation contract, so the landlord must register with Rent Smart Wales, and anyone doing letting or management work needs a licence. A genuine holiday let is not an occupation contract, so those requirements do not apply to it.
A short let in Wales has its own requirements. Every provider must register with the Welsh Revenue Authority by 31 March 2027. The visitor levy applies in Cardiff. Whether you pay council tax or business rates depends on how often the property is available and let. A licensing scheme has also been passed into law, though it is not yet live. Our guide to holiday let rules in Wales walks through each one.
A short let in England does not yet need registration. As of 21 October 2026, GOV.UK says a national register is expected to begin in March 2027, with details still to be published.
Either way, check your mortgage and lease before you let. Many lenders and leases restrict short lets, so get any permission you need in writing first. You also need insurance that covers your chosen type of letting.
Effort and control
A long-term tenancy is largely hands-off once a good tenant is in place. The trade-off is less flexibility. You cannot use the property yourself, and ending a tenancy follows a legal process that takes time.
A short let needs attention every day: changing prices, answering guests, organising cleans, restocking and fixing things quickly. In return, you keep control of the calendar. You can block dates for your own use, change direction if your plans change, and inspect the property often.
Which suits which owner?
| Long-term let | Short let | |
|---|---|---|
| Income pattern | Steady and predictable | Varies by season and demand |
| Running costs to you | Lower | Higher |
| Your time, if self-managed | Low | High |
| Use of the property yourself | Not while it is let | Possible, by blocking dates |
| Furnishing | Often unfurnished | Fully furnished and equipped |
| Wales registration | Rent Smart Wales | Welsh Revenue Authority |
| Wear and tear | Over a long tenancy | Frequent, but checked often |
Mid-term and contractor stays
Some owners sit between the two, letting for a few weeks or months to contractors, hospital staff or people between homes. In Wales, whether a stay counts as a holiday is a question of fact. If it is really someone's home, it may be an occupation contract, and Rent Smart Wales registration and licensing would then apply. Take advice if your lets will mix holidays with longer stays.
Questions to ask yourself before switching
Does my mortgage, lease and insurance allow short lets?
Is there steady guest demand where my property is, all year round?
Can I cover the cost of furnishing and the quieter months?
Do I want to use the property myself sometimes?
Who will deal with guests, cleans and repairs, day and night?
How StayRight helps
If you are weighing up a switch, we can give you an honest view of how your property might perform as a short let. With full management, pricing is tuned daily, guests are vetted with security deposits taken, housekeeping comes with hotel-quality linen and maintenance is handled. You see every booking on your owner dashboard, and payouts arrive automatically after checkout. StayRight's fee for full management is 12.5% + VAT.
See what full management includes, then request an income estimate for your property.
If your property is in Cardiff, South Wales or Nottingham, our area pages show the kinds of homes we already run as short lets there.
Sources
This guide is general information, not legal or tax advice. Check the sources above or speak to an adviser for your situation.
Questions
Is Airbnb more profitable than a long-term let?
Sometimes, but not always. A short let can earn more in a location with strong year-round demand, but it also costs more to run and its income varies. The only reliable way to know is to estimate both for your own property, after every cost.
Do I need Rent Smart Wales for a short let?
Not for a genuine holiday let, which is not an occupation contract. If you let the property as someone's home, registration and licensing apply to that let.
Can I switch back to a long-term let later?
Usually, yes. If you return to long-term letting in Wales, you will need Rent Smart Wales registration and licensing for that tenancy, and your council tax position may change. Check your mortgage and insurance at each switch.
Did the tax change make holiday lets less attractive?
It removed several tax advantages, including full relief on mortgage interest. Whether a short let still makes sense now depends far more on your property's income and costs than on tax alone, so get advice for your own situation.