Last checked
Reviewed by Abbie Leeson
Key points
Start with what you want from the property
Before you compare managers, be clear about your own goals. Do you want the highest income you can get, or a steady return with as little involvement as possible? Will you use the property yourself at times? How much of your week are you willing to give it?
Your answers point you towards a type of service before you ever look at a name. A manager who suits an owner chasing maximum income may not suit one who wants a quiet, predictable arrangement.
The main ways to run a let
Broadly, you can choose between the routes below, and each one shares the work differently.
| Self-managing | Co-host | Full management | Long-term letting agent | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Who prices the nights | You | Often shared | The manager | Not applicable: fixed rent |
| Who answers guests | You | The co-host | The manager | Tenant contacts the agent |
| Cleaning and linen | You arrange it | Often arranged by the co-host | Run by the manager | Tenant's responsibility |
| Repairs | You arrange them | Often shared | Handled by the manager | Agent arranges, you approve |
| Your time | High | Medium | Low | Low |
| How you pay | Your own time and costs | A fee for a narrower service | A fee for the full service | A fee on the rent |
| Income pattern | Varies by night | Varies by night | Varies by night | Fixed monthly rent |
Self-managing keeps every decision and every penny of fees with you, but it also leaves you with every late-night message and every missed clean.
A co-host takes on part of the work, typically guest communication and arranging cleans, while you keep the rest. It can suit owners who live nearby and want to stay involved.
Full management hands the day-to-day running to one company: pricing, guests, cleaning, linen, repairs and payouts. It suits owners who want the property run properly without running it themselves.
A long-term letting agent finds and manages a tenant on a tenancy. It is a different product with different rules, and in Wales it brings Rent Smart Wales registration and licensing. If you are still deciding between a tenancy and a short let, start with that decision.
How fee models differ
Managers price their services in different ways: a percentage of booking income, a fixed monthly charge, a co-host fee for a narrower service, or an arrangement where a company rents the property from you. The headline figure is only the beginning. What the percentage is calculated on, whether VAT is included and which costs are billed separately all change what you keep.
Our guide to how much Airbnb management companies charge explains how to compare quotes like for like.
Questions to ask any manager
About the team
Who will actually look after my property, and where are they based?
Who answers guests, at what hours, and how quickly?
Are cleaners and maintenance staff your own, or subcontracted?
About income
How do you set prices, and how often do you change them?
Where will guests be able to find and book my home?
Do you offer a direct booking route as well?
How will I see each booking, what was charged and every deduction, and when will I be paid?
About protecting the property
How do you vet guests, and do you take security deposits?
What repairs can you approve without asking me first, and up to what amount?
How are damage and claims handled?
About compliance
Who carries out the fire risk assessment and arranges gas safety checks?
In Wales, who handles registration with the Welsh Revenue Authority, and, in Cardiff, the visitor levy?
How do you keep up with changes to the rules?
About the contract
How long is the minimum term, and what is the notice period?
Are there exit fees?
If I leave, who keeps the listing, photos and reviews, and what happens to future bookings?
If you own in Wales, our guide to holiday let rules in Wales will help you judge how well a manager understands the local requirements.
Red flags
Be cautious if a manager:
quotes a percentage without saying clearly what it is charged on
promises a specific income without explaining how the figure was worked out
will not show you how owners see their bookings and payouts, or put you in touch with a current owner
asks for a long lock-in with heavy exit fees
is vague about who is responsible for safety and compliance
cannot tell you who answers guests outside office hours
pressures you to sign quickly
None of these proves a manager is a poor choice, but each deserves a straight answer before you commit.
Checking what a manager tells you
Do not rely on the sales conversation alone. Read reviews from guests and from owners, and look at how the manager responds to criticism. Ask to see a property they manage, or at least its live listing, and judge the photographs and description as a guest would. Ask a current owner what the first few months were really like.
Then compare the money and the service side by side. The cheapest offer is not always the one that leaves you with the most, once poor reviews, empty nights and repair bills are counted.
How StayRight compares on these questions
We are happy to be measured against the questions above. StayRight is led by directors Zac Ratcliffe and Eve D'Arcy, and we are rated 4.1 on Google from 189 reviews. With full management, pricing is tuned daily, every guest is vetted with a security deposit taken, and guests can reach our in-house team 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, with replies within 20 minutes. Housekeeping comes with hotel-quality linen, maintenance is handled, and you can follow every booking and charge on your owner dashboard. Our fee is 12.5% + VAT.
The full detail is on our pricing page. If you would like to put your own questions to us, contact the team.
To see how we work in your area, start with our pages for Cardiff, Swansea, South Wales, Birmingham, Nottingham and Bristol.
Sources
This guide is general information, not legal or tax advice. Check the sources above or speak to an adviser for your situation.
Questions
Is a co-host cheaper than a management company?
A co-host fee can be lower, because the service is narrower. Once you add the jobs you still do yourself, and the cost of your own time, the difference may be smaller than it first looks.
Should I pick the manager with the lowest fee?
Not on fee alone. Compare what each manager would pay you from the same example booking, what the fee covers, and how well they are likely to run the property.
How long do Airbnb management contracts last?
It varies from manager to manager. Some run month to month, others ask for a minimum term. Read the notice period and any exit fees before you sign.
What should a management contract include?
The fee and what it is charged on, what is included and what costs extra, how and when you are paid, spending limits for repairs, who is responsible for compliance, the notice period, and what happens to your listing when the agreement ends.